"Not Small Talk."
Showing posts with label film. Show all posts
Showing posts with label film. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Akira Kurosawa's Ran

The title promises chaos.  It does not fail to deliver.

Ran cobbles together elements of King Lear and Macbeth to spectacular effect, proving the universality of Shakespeare's vision.  At the same time, Ran is wholly original, the work of an auteur whose vision had grown and changed as he entered the final phases of his career.  Unlike the aging Lord Hidetora, however, Kurosawa does not lose his finely wrought command of the situation.  We have, I suspect, inspiration from traditional Noh theatre in the sometimes elaborate formality of the the acting.  This formality is offset, though, by scenes that unfold more naturally, scenes in which human actions take place with a kind of inevitability as far beyond our ken or control as the clouds that brood dramatically but affectlessly over the battlefields and heaths of the film.  The director himself, after decades of staying true to black and white, takes on the primary color palette in its most fundamental form, catching up on technicolor with a vengeance.  Besides the red, yellow, and blue of the flags of the Ichimonji clan, we have blood that washes over the whole film in streams, rivulets, flood beds that usually run dry but not now.  Blood doesn't just flow here; it spurts, jets, sprays across the frame.  The stylized unreality of it is pointed, deliberate.  Thus there is another element, that of horror.  The pale, ghastly flesh of Lord Hidetora as he confronts the reality of his sons' mistreatment of him reflects the nightmarish quality of his experience.  The film is heavily stylized but also bears elements of realism.  We are watching something foreign but at the same time Shakespearean in its universality.  The experience is, I imagine, not so different from that of sitting in the Elizabethan theatre.

Unlike King Lear, though, we have no Edgar to emerge victorious and restore a new order even as the protagonist, the exemplar of the old order, dies.  Ran is much more nihilistic than Shakespeare's bleakest.  In keeping with its Elizabethan antecedent, Ran does at the end briefly give us a sense that family bonds can be meaningful, after all, but then snatches that sentiment away from us.  There is no justice in the universe, says King Lear, unless we impose it upon the world ourselves through our wills.  Edgar will do so in Lear.  Ran instead leaves us with a parting image of the gods' blindness and impotence.  The only order that ever was in this world was written in blood, and this is the inevitable result of it. 

I had the great fortune of viewing this film once on the big screen at AFI's Silver Theatre in Maryland. The colors were vivid, terrifying, magnificent.  There is a powerful but brutal beauty to this film, the kind that only a master at his peak can produce.

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Spielberg's Lincoln

There could be many ways of putting Abraham Lincoln on film, but most of them would be wrong.  The subject is a tough one: the heft of it threatens almost from the start to make the project collapse.  A light touch is essential.  Steven Spielberg, then, is a perilous choice for this occasion.  Spielberg's films have in the past sometimes given way under their own weight.  To wit: Saving Private Ryan, a film too full of cheap patriotism, sentimentality, and melodrama -- an action film that aspires to do too great things.  Fortunately, Spielberg's Lincoln is not Saving Private Ryan.  Lincoln, instead, displays the subtlety necessary to do justice to its subject.  It is unequivocally a great film.

Part of what makes the film work is that it wisely chooses to focus not on the big picture but on a central event of the Lincoln presidency: the passage of the Thirteenth Amendment, the one that Constitutionally forbade slavery, in 1865.  The Emancipation Proclamation of 1863 was a daring rhetorical act, but it held no legal staying power; Lincoln knew that he had to get this amendment through in order for his previous actions to hold any meaning -- and in order for the war to truly settle the matter of the South's "peculiar institution" once and for all. 

It helps that Spielberg has Daniel Day-Lewis on hand to play the title character.  Day-Lewis's Lincoln has a kind of stately presence that one senses is more accountable to his height than to any sense of self-importance, but it's a quality of which Lincoln seems to have taken advantage.  Lincoln lumbers through each scene like a minor giant, but this bearing seems natural and unaffected.  Lincoln's voice is more a train-whistle whine than a deep chugging baritone that we expect, but the effect is perhaps all the better.  (As Day-Lewis noted in an interview for the New York Times, his operating assumption was that such a voice carried better in a crowd.)  We sense that here is a man who took everyone by surprise: the country lawyer who proved a savant, who made his way in a political milieu that more typically favored the cultural elites.  Day-Lewis's Lincoln has a certain peculiar grace that is charming.  He grins through minor turmoils but we never doubt that he feels the weight of things very heavily.  He's homespun and plainspoken without being aw-shucks cornpone.  In other words, he seems like a possible and plausible human being.

Day-Lewis's performance would have gone nowhere, however, if it weren't for Tony Kushner's script, which did something very few films of this type manage to accomplish: it gives us dialogue that is actually convincingly of the film's own historical time and not of our own. The script is almost entirely free of the modern cliches that populate so many other historical films.  Each character has his or her own lively and distinct idiom, with Lincoln's being the most distinctive of all, though that of Thaddeus Stephens (Tommy Lee Jones) is certainly comparable in vibrancy.  What Kushner captures best in Lincoln's language is the wide-ranging dynamics of which he was capable, the shifting from a natural low register to a soaringly high register as situation and circumstance demand.  Lincoln is one moment folksy, plainspoken, humorous, capable even of some lesser vulgarities, and in the next moment he is deeply sincere, projecting a thoughtfulness that is profound.  The core essence of Lincoln's character is, to my mind, captured in a conversation between the President and the staff men in the telegraph room, a conversation that hinges on a chance discussion of Euclid's geometry and which proves, in this narrative, to be a defining moment, one that more or less saves the day.  This speech act is, needless to say, not one of Lincoln's famous moments, but it succeeds because it captures Lincoln's best quality -- his thoughtfulness -- in a convincing way.  As for the more famous words, they bookend the film.  The Gettysburg Address is recited here in tandem by a group of soldiers in the early moments of the film, which to my mind is the proper way to present it.  If we started with Lincoln himself mouthing the words, the film would never have been able to recover.  After a restrained and modest touch -- one displaying the lightness, the deftness sometimes missing from the director's work -- Spielberg deserves the chance to present the final lines of Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address -- perhaps the President's best speech -- in their full resplendent glory near the film's close.

Spielberg's chiaroscuro is impressive. It's hard to think of anyone since Orson Welles who used light and shadow so magisterially.  There's an impressive balance of levity and gravity here.  In all, the film works.